refinishing vs replacing a hardwood gym floor.

A Cost-Benefit Analysis of Refinishing vs. Replacing a Hardwood gym Floor


Deciding between refinishing vs. replacing your gym’s hardwood floor significantly impacts aesthetics and budget. If you’re noticing wear and tear on your gym’s hardwood floor, then you’re likely weighing the costs and benefits of each. This article will guide you through the crucial considerations and financial implications of each option.

But the first step in deciding about your gym flooring options is understanding how wear and tear affect a gym floor’s performance. 

Understanding Hardwood Floor Lifespan and Wear

With proper maintenance, wood gym flooring can last 20 to 50 years. A regular cleaning schedule helps to ensure longevity. Additionally, avoiding potential issues like water damage is crucial to prevent costly repairs. Refinishing the gym floor every five to ten years ensures the hardwood sports floor lasts its lifetime. 

Of course, hardwood gym floors must withstand heavy foot traffic, especially if high-impact sports like basketball, volleyball, or indoor soccer are played. Over time, the hardwood floor may show signs of wear and tear, from dents and scratches to discolorations and warped boards. This type of wear can impact the wooden floor’s performance. 

Here are some ways regular wear can affect gym flooring:

  • Surface scratches diminish the floor’s aesthetics and traction.
  • A worn gym floor finish reduces protection, making the wood vulnerable to damage.
  • An uneven surface increases injury risk.
  • Loose floorboards compromise structural integrity and safety.
  • Cupping or crowning affects ball bounce and player stability.
  • Squeaks indicate potential structural issues and disrupt play.
  • Water damage warps the wood, impacting appearance and structural stability. 

At some point, you must assess whether refinishing or replacing the gym floor is necessary. Applying a coat of finish for minor issues, like a worn gym floor finish, can help restore the floor. However, water damage, an uneven surface, or loose boards may require a complete replacement. 

Refinishing Hardwood Floors: Process, Costs, and Benefits

Refinishing a hardwood gym floor enhances durability, appearance, and performance. It repairs wear, extends lifespan, and ensures a safe playing surface. Maintaining a gym floor provides athletes with an optimal and visually appealing environment.

The gym floor refinishing process usually consists of the following steps:

  • Gym floor sanding: Specialized sanding equipment removes the existing finish and sands to the raw wood. The area is then cleaned to remove dust and grime.
  • Repairs: The contractors inspect the entire floor to assess its condition and make the necessary repairs. The floor may be sanded with a finer grit to prepare for sealing.
  • Sealing: A sealer is applied to protect the wood. The floor may be slightly sanded to prepare it for finishing.
  • Applying finish: The professional flooring contractor will apply a quality sports floor finish. Multiple coats are usually applied with drying and light sanding between coats. During this time, sports lines, markers, and logos are installed.
  • Final inspection: A final assessment ensures the gym floor sanding and finishing process is successful and ready for use.

The average cost to sand and refinish a gym floor is $2 to 3$ per square foot. However, the final cost depends on the scope of work, materials used, extent of damaged floorboards, and any customization. 

The benefits of refinishing a gymnasium floor every five to ten years include the following:

  • Extend the life of the wood gym floor
  • Improve the attractiveness of hardwood flooring
  • Reduce the need for costly repairs 

Replacing Hardwood Floors: When It’s Necessary and What It Entails

At some point, replacing a wood gym floor is necessary. With proper care and an excellent maintenance program, the hardwood flooring may last for 50 years or more. However, a gym floor replacement may be necessary to remediate extensive damage.

Here are some scenarios when there is no other option than replacing the entire flooring system:

  • Severe damage: Extensive water damage, severe warping, or structural issues may render the floor irreparable, necessitating replacement. Refinishing is not an option to repair gym floor damage in these cases.
  • Safety concerns: Suppose the floor becomes uneven, develops significant gaps, or has loose boards. In that case, the floor poses significant safety risks, requiring replacement to ensure a secure playing surface.
  • Significant wear: When you sand the current finish down to raw wood, you remove a layer of wood from the floorboards. In time, the floorboards lose effectiveness, and the floor no longer performs as it should.
  • Changes in facility usage: Alterations in the gymnasium’s purpose or usage may require a wood flooring contractor to replace the entire floor.

Comparative Analysis: Refinishing vs. Replacing

Refinishing a maple sports floor can cost between $2 and $3 per square foot. The cost of replacing gym flooring can range between $6 and $12 per square foot. 

Refinishing a gym floor is typically part of the regular maintenance program. Sealing the floor with a new coat of finish restores it to its original condition. The length of time between refinishing depends on its use. You can expect downtime of around two weeks. 

Replacing a gym floor is necessary due to long-term wear or unexpected damage. The replacement cost involves flooring materials and labor. You can expect the entire process to take around eight to ten weeks.

Additional Considerations

Refinishing or replacing a gym floor can transform the appearance of your sports facilities. It’s also a long-term investment, ensuring users have the best experience possible. However, there are a few additional things to consider before choosing the best option. Here they are:

  • Choose the optimal time for flooring repairs to reduce downtime
  • Explore sustainable options to reduce your carbon footprint
  • Hire a professional sports flooring company for the best long-term results
  • Consider investing in gym flooring that utilizes the latest technological advances

Final Thoughts on Refinishing vs. Replacing Your Gym’s Hardwood Floor

Refinishing your gym’s hardwood floor is the best option when dealing with minor damage to the floor’s surface. This is a cost-effective option with a quick turnaround time to maximize the floor’s lifespan.

However, considerable damage or extensive wear requires replacing the entire flooring system. In any case, it’s best to consult a professional to determine the most appropriate solution for your gymnasium floor.

Are you considering refinishing or replacing your gym’s hardwood floor? Contact J&J Gym Floors for a free consultation. We’re committed to providing excellent customer service and high-quality flooring to ensure your gym’s hardwood floor looks and performs its best. Our experienced experts can help you determine the best course of action for restoring your gym floor.

Got A Project In Mind?

Reach out to us for a fast response!





Time-Lapse Videos

New Gym Floor Installation

Gym Floor Sanding & Refinishing

Gym Floor Sanding & Refinishing​​

Gym Floor Sanding & Refinishing​

our service area

J & J Gym Floors is a full-service gym floor company. Established in 2000, we’ve completed more than 35,000 projects for various types of facilities: NBA basketball courts, college gym floors, high school gymnasiums, K-8 gym floors as well as fitness centers, YMCAs and Jewish Community Centers. We also done some amazing work for homeowners and professional athletes! 

We specialize in: gym floor screening and recoating, basketball court sanding and refinishing, new gym floor installations, gymnasium wall padding, expert gym floor repairs as well as gym floor designs, graphics, logos and game lines.

We’re proud to service the following areas: New Jersey, New York (including NYC‘s five boroughs: Manhattan, Brooklyn, The Bronx, Queens & Staten Island), as well as all of Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland and Rhode Island. 

We’re based in Northern New Jersey and we service most of NJ, NY, NYC, CT, PA, DE, MD & RI.
Don’t see your state or county located below? Kindly contact us to review your project.

New Jersey

Bergen County, Passaic County, Sussex County, Hudson County, Essex County, Morris County, Union County, Somerset County, Middlesex County, Hunterdon County, Warren County, Monmouth County, Ocean County, Mercer County, Burlington County, Camden County, Atlantic County, Gloucester County, Salem County, Cumberland County and Cape May County

New York

NYC, Manhattan, Queens, Bronx, Brooklyn, Staten Island, Long Island, Nassau County, Suffolk County, Rockland County, Orange County, Westchester County, Putnam County, Sullivan County, Ulster County, Dutchess County, Delaware County, Greene County, Columbia County, Otsego County, Schoharie County, Albany County and Rensselaer County


Fairfield County, New Haven County, Litchfield County, Middlesex County, Hartford County, Tolland County, New London County and Windham County


Bucks County, Philadelphia, Wayne County, Pike County, Monroe County, Northampton County, Chester County, Berks County, Lehigh County, Carbon County, Luzerne County, Lackawanna County, Wyoming County and Susquehanna County


Garrett County, Allegany County, Washington County, Frederick County, Carroll County, Baltimore County, Harford County, Cecil County, Kent County, Queen Anne’s County, Caroline County, Talbot County, Dorchester County, Wicomico County, Worcester County, Somerset County, Montgomery County, Howard County, Anne Arundel County, Prince George’s County, Charles County and Saint Mary’s County


New Castle County, Kent County and Sussex County

Rhode Island

Bristol County, Kent County, Newport County, Providence County, and Washington County
Request a Quote

Got A Project In Mind?

Reach out to us for a fast response!

gym floor company
gym floor company
gym floor refinishing
gym floor company
gym floor refinishing
gym floor
gym floor company
gym floor company